New Institute of Political Economy

The Case for a Federal Commission for Crypto Trading

by Harry Whomersley

The recent scandals in the cryptocurrency industry, most notably the bankruptcy of FTX and its related partner Alameda Holdings, have led to a resurgence of cryptocurrency skepticism. But the seemingly simple question of whether cryptocurrencies should be regulated by the federal government masks a number of complex issues which go to the heart of what cryptocurrencies actually are and what role they play in today’s economy. This report aims to clarify the nature of cryptocurrencies and propose a regulatory framework appropriate to them.

Contrary to the beliefs of some cryptocurrency supporters, the industry does not offer a viable alternative to traditional fiat currencies or a stable means of wealth building for marginalized communities.On the other hand, a strongly crypto-skeptical view, colloquially referred to as “let crypto burn,” has gained currency in mainstream commentary, arguing that the cryptocurrency industry would only be legitimized by regulation and should instead be allowed to peter out of its own accord.

Both these perspectives are deeply flawed. Cryptocurrency boosterism in Washington was not the result of a clear-eyed consideration of the merits of the issue but instead the result of a large lobbying effort bankrolled by the industry. Meanwhile, the hope that cryptocurrency may simply disappear if ignored is naive. The decentralized nature of the industry means that even if public interest decreases, there will still be individuals or groups working on cryptocurrency development and unscrupulous individuals will continue to use it for fraudulent purposes or to defraud less sophisticated investors.

But this does not mean that regulation of cryptocurrencies should necessarily be handed over to an existing agency. Cryptocurrencies are not tied to any underlying assets, being purely speculative tokens, marking them out as very different from existing forms of financial assets such as commodities or securities. It would be impossible to require cryptocurrency issuers to make, for example, the kinds of regulatory disclosures routinely required of issuers of securities or commodities. The price fluctuations routinely experienced by cryptocurrency tokens are purely the result of animal spirits and any regulatory approach will have to reflect that reality.

This report outlines a regulatory framework which borrows significantly from existing gambling regulations, while building out a series of best practices which will ensure that consumers are protected from the worst excesses of the industry. It recommends the creation of a federal commission empowered to grant licenses to issuers of cryptocurrencies and to the owners of the exchanges upon which they can be legally traded. This commission will be empowered to regulate the manner in which cryptocurrency blockchains are updated, and who can purchase cryptocurrencies and in what quantities. This report is divided into two parts: an examination of the nature of cryptocurrencies and a description of the proposed regulatory commission. In addition, an appendix provides a brief overview of other types of digital assets and their regulation.

The Case for a Federal Commission for Crypto Trading